Compromise tax bill should pass

Editorials

Discussion

March 1, 2006

Anonymous The Meridian Star Wed Mar 01, 2006, 07:23 AM CST

New bills to increase Mississippi's cigarette tax and reduce its grocery tax are imperfect but much improved over a bill vetoed by Gov. Haley Barbour earlier in the legislative session.

Barbour's principle objections to the earlier bill — that cutting the grocery tax is unwise in a time of fiscal uncertainty for the state and that municipal governments would be hit especially hard by the loss of revenue — are answered in at least one of the compromise bills, House Bill 1643.

The Mississippi Municipal League, which led the opposition to the bill that Barbour vetoed, says the new House bill would keep city budgets whole.

Barbour, who barely mentioned the cigarette tax in his earlier veto message, has returned to his "no tax increase" mantra as the basis for opposing the compromise legislation. We share some of the governor's concerns, but the benefits of the legislation outweigh its flaws.

We especially like the idea of cutting the grocery tax, arguably Mississippi's most regressive tax. There's something very wrong with one of the poorest states levying the highest tax in the nation on one of life's necessities: food. Liberals and conservatives alike should applaud the gesture — conservatives because they dislike taxes and liberals because they care about the plight of poor people, who would have more disposable income to devote to other needs.

As for the cigarette tax, we're philosophically troubled by the modern trend of using tax codes to influence behavior and morality. An overnight quadrupling of the tax on a legal product, as would happen with the proposed cigarette tax increase from 18 cents to 80 cents or $1, is excessive.

However, we believe strongly in tax equity, and there's no disputing the inequity of Mississippi's having one of the nation's lowest cigarette taxes and the country's highest tax on groceries. We'd prefer a smaller increase in the cigarette tax, but in combination with the lower grocery tax, we can live with the bigger jump.

The Senate should accept the House's version of the compromise legislation, and Barbour should resist the urge to veto it. With the concern about municipal budgets having been answered, he'd be hard-pressed to corral enough votes to sustain a veto.

Text Only

Editorials

Depraved hoax or desperate exposure?
April 30, 2012
No Rand Heroes on November Card
April 23, 2012
Honoring a legacy
I.A. "Al" Rosenbaum's death left a large void in East Mississippi this past week.

March 25, 2012
Pardons should stay in the hands of the executive branch
March 18, 2012
Take advantage of unique opportunity
March 11, 2012
Gas price politics belie facts
February 27, 2012
All about priorities
This past week the City of Meridian unveiled its new City Council chambers in the renovated City Hall for the first regular council meeting in the new building.

February 26, 2012
City makes right decision
Kudos to members of the Meridian City Council for voting this week to stop paying Watkins Development their $10,000 monthly consulting fee until work resumes on city projects.

February 12, 2012
Spring revival time
February 10, 2012
Military cuts and BRAC to challenge leaders
February 6, 2012
More Editorials Headlines

Editorials

Search Results

Discussion

Compromise tax bill should pass

Site Map

Contact Us